Supreme Court Yearly Digest 2025
A Year of Constitutional Calibration, Institutional Reform & Rights Enforcement
The Supreme Court Annual Digest 2025 chronicles a pivotal year for India’s judiciary — one defined not by judicial overreach, but by measured constitutional engineering. Under three successive Chief Justices — Sanjiv Khanna, B.R. Gavai, and Surya Kant — the Court reshaped doctrine across arbitration, federalism, judicial appointments, and civil liberties.
Rather than sweeping ideological declarations, 2025 stands out for its system-building jurisprudence: refining procedures, enforcing accountability, and converting rights from rhetoric into remedies.
I. Landmark Constitution Bench Judgments
1. Modification of Arbitral Awards
Gayatri Balasamy v. ISG Novasoft Technologies (5-Judge Bench, 4:1)
Courts now possess a limited power to modify arbitral awards under Section 34 — allowing severance of non-arbitrable parts and correction of clerical or mathematical errors. This replaces the rigid “set aside or nothing” regime.
Impact: Arbitration becomes faster, cheaper, and less prone to endless litigation cycles.
2. Governor’s Assent Powers – Presidential Reference
The Court held that Governors and the President cannot indefinitely withhold assent to Bills. While rejecting rigid timelines and “deemed assent,” it introduced the doctrine of “limited mandamus” to curb arbitrary delay.
Impact: Federal balance restored without converting courts into supervisory authorities.
3. District Judge Recruitment Eligibility
Rejanish K.V. v. K. Deepa (5-Judge Bench)
Judicial officers who practiced at the Bar for seven years before joining service remain eligible for direct recruitment as District Judges.
Impact: Merit and experience prevail over technical status barriers.
4. Higher Judicial Service (HJS) Seniority Roster
A uniform four-point roster system was introduced to ensure equitable representation between promotees, direct recruits and departmental candidates.
Impact: Transparency and uniformity across States.
II. Civil Rights & Social Justice
Transgender Employment Rights
Compensation awarded to a transgender woman denied appointment. The Court clarified that gender-affirming medical procedures do not require employer permission unless job-specific functionality is affected.
Shift: From symbolic rights to enforceable remedies.
Right to Housing
Declared as an intrinsic part of Article 21 – Right to Life, mandating real-estate regulators to protect homebuyers against exploitative practices.
Maternity Leave
Denial of maternity leave due to the “two-child norm” in second marriages was held unconstitutional, affirming reproductive autonomy and dignity.
Waqf Act Interim Scrutiny
The Court stayed select provisions mandating five-year religious practice and shifting title disputes to executive officers.
III. Criminal Law & Procedural Safeguards
Arrest Safeguards Strengthened
Written grounds of arrest must be provided in a language understood by the accused. Non-compliance invalidates arrest and remand. Extended to GST and Customs laws.
Abetment of Suicide
“Mere refusal to marry” or ordinary quarrels do not constitute abetment. Clear mens rea and direct instigation are mandatory.
Juvenility Claims
Claims can be raised at any stage, even decades later — reaffirming the reformative philosophy of juvenile justice.
IV. Judicial Administration & Institutional Reforms
Oral Hearing Reforms
Under CJI Surya Kant, time-bound oral argument structures were introduced, prioritising vulnerable litigants.
Judicial Asset Disclosure
The Supreme Court resumed public declaration of assets of judges — restoring public trust in judicial integrity.
Collegium Appointments
Seven new judges were elevated with a visible emphasis on regional, gender and social diversity.
V. Advocates, Bar Reforms & Professional Ethics
Major reforms dismantled the mechanical 100-point system for Senior Advocate designation and mandated High Courts to adopt holistic merit-based evaluations with minimum 10 years’ practice.
Principles reinforced:
-
Professional duty equals professional right.
-
No optional Bar Council fees beyond statute.
-
Mandatory decorum and accountability.
VI. Commercial Law & Insolvency
Arbitration
Ambiguous arbitration clauses were condemned as judicial waste. Courts were empowered to reject mala fide clauses suo motu.
Insolvency
Liquidation is not the goal — revival is the soul of IBC. Where resolution applicants are faultless, revival must prevail.
VII. Environment & Development
Ex-Post Facto Environmental Clearances
Allowed in rare cases — though a strong dissent warned against dilution of the precautionary principle.
Conflict remains: Growth pragmatism vs environmental absolutism.
VIII. Senior Citizens & Welfare
Under the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, tribunals were empowered to protect elderly parents even where property had been transferred to ungrateful heirs.
The Rule-Making Through Restraint Year
2025 was not loud. It was precise.
The Supreme Court:
-
Replaced rhetoric with procedural discipline.
-
Converted rights into enforceable remedies.
-
Balanced federalism with institutional accountability.
-
Chose calibration over confrontation.
In constitutional memory, 2025 will be remembered as the year the Court didn’t shout — it engineered.
