Rahul Gandhi Moves Supreme Court to Serve 48 Questions on Election Commission: Did All Three Election Commissioners Approve ECI’s Affidavit? Were Their Objections to SIR Recorded?
Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi, Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge and several INDIA bloc leaders have approached the Supreme Court seeking permission to serve 48 formal written questions, known as interrogatories, on the Election Commission of India (ECI) over its nationwide Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls.
The application seeks answers on how the nationwide SIR was authorised, whether all three Election Commissioners approved the decisions, and whether the Chief Election Commissioner exercised the Commission’s collective powers without the knowledge or concurrence of the other two members.
One of the most significant questions concerns the Election Commission’s affidavit filed before the Supreme Court on October 26. The ECI had maintained that all three members of the Commission unanimously approved the decisions relating to SIR.
However, the INDIA bloc leaders now want the Commission to disclose whether Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar and Election Commissioners Dr Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Dr Vivek Joshi individually approved the affidavit submitted through Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu.
The petitioners have also asked whether approval was granted during a formal meeting, through circulation of files or by electronic communication. They want the relevant dates, file numbers and documentary records establishing the approval of each Commissioner.
Another crucial aspect concerns whether the two Election Commissioners recorded any objections, disagreements or reservations regarding the SIR exercise, ECINET, changes to Form 6 or the Commission’s decisions to pursue certain court appeals.
The 48 questions specifically seek details of every occasion between February 19, 2025, and October 26, 2026, when either Commissioner recorded a written objection, dissent or reservation. The petitioners also want to know whether any decisions were taken by majority rather than unanimously.
The application raises questions about an apparent discrepancy between the Election Commission’s claim of unanimous approval for nationwide SIR and an earlier Right to Information response dated August 27, 2025, which reportedly stated that no information was available regarding a decision to initiate a nationwide revision.
The opposition leaders are also seeking information about who authorised the insertion of an additional declaration into the online Form 6 voter-registration process, when the change was approved and whether any Commissioner objected to it.
Several questions concern the functioning of ECINET and ERONET, the digital platforms used for electoral-roll management. The petitioners want clarification on whether private contractors or vendors had the ability to modify electoral-roll databases and whether bulk deletions or modifications could take place without individual orders from Electoral Registration Officers.
The application further seeks information about access logs, database audits and the technical safeguards available to restore voters’ names after deletion. It also asks what action was taken on Election Commissioner Vivek Joshi’s reported proposal for an audit of individuals having access to the electoral-roll database.
The opposition leaders have additionally sought state-wise and Union Territory-wise information about voters excluded from draft and final electoral rolls, the reasons for their exclusion, the number of applications rejected or kept pending, and the procedures followed before deleting names.
The INDIA bloc has requested that Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu answer the factual questions. However, where the matters concern individual approval, consent or disagreement, the application seeks separate sworn affidavits from the Chief Election Commissioner and the two Election Commissioners. The Director General (IT) has also been identified for answering technical questions.
The Election Commission, in its earlier affidavits, has rejected the allegation that the Chief Election Commissioner acted unilaterally. It has maintained that the three SIR orders dated June 24, 2025, October 27, 2025, and May 14, 2026, were approved unanimously by all three members.
The Supreme Court had earlier issued notices to the Election Commission and the three Commissioners on the opposition leaders’ main petition challenging aspects of the SIR exercise and the Commission’s decision-making process.
The fresh application does not mean that the Supreme Court has already established any disagreement among the Commissioners or found irregularities in the affidavit. The 48 questions are requests for disclosure, and the Commission’s responses, if directed by the Court, will be part of the proceedings.
The Supreme Court is scheduled to hear the connected SIR matters on November 17, 2026. The Court’s consideration of the interrogatories application could determine whether the Election Commission will have to provide more detailed, individual and sworn explanations about its internal decision-making.
At the centre of the legal dispute are three important questions: Who actually authorised the nationwide SIR? Did all three Election Commissioners approve the decisions and the affidavit? And were any objections or disagreements recorded in the Commission’s official files?
The answers could provide the Supreme Court with a clearer picture of the decision-making procedures followed by India’s constitutional election authority during the electoral-roll revision exercise.