Supreme Court of India Sets Aside Punjab and Haryana High Court Order Over “Hallucination of Facts” and Lack of Judicial Application of Mind
In a sharp observation, the Supreme Court of India has set aside an order passed by the Punjab and Haryana High Court, criticizing the judgment for what it described as a “hallucination of facts” and complete non-application of judicial mind. The apex court observed that the High Court’s findings were unsupported by the actual records placed before it and appeared to be based on assumptions rather than verified facts.
The Supreme Court emphasized that judicial orders must be founded on careful examination of evidence, pleadings, and applicable law, especially when such decisions directly affect the rights and liberties of parties involved. Expressing concern over the manner in which the impugned order was passed, the bench remarked that courts cannot rely on imaginary or non-existent facts while adjudicating disputes.
The ruling is being viewed as a significant reminder on the importance of judicial discipline, factual accuracy, and reasoned decision-making within the justice delivery system. Legal observers believe the judgment reinforces the principle that higher courts must ensure that orders passed by subordinate courts and High Courts adhere strictly to constitutional and legal standards.
